Author Guidelines

The Author Guidelines of Tsiqah: Jurnal Studi Hadis dan Tradisi Kenabian have been developed in accordance with international academic publishing standards and the scholarly orientation of the journal. Authors are strongly encouraged to read these guidelines carefully before submitting their work for editorial consideration. The journal publishes original and high-quality research focusing on Hadith studies, Hadith sciences, Sunnah studies, Prophetic traditions, sanad and matn criticism, hadith interpretation, living Hadith, digital Hadith studies, religious authority, knowledge transmission, Hadith manuscripts, Southeast Asian Hadith scholarship, and interdisciplinary approaches to Prophetic traditions in Muslim societies.

Publishing an article in Tsiqah: Jurnal Studi Hadis dan Tradisi Kenabian means that the author(s) retain copyright of the published work while granting the journal the right of first publication. The journal applies the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided that the original work is properly cited. Authors are therefore allowed to archive, distribute, and share their published work for academic and non-commercial purposes.

Shortcuts

Article Submission Overview

Article Preparation

Article Structure

References and Citation Style

Arabic Transliteration

Tables, Figures, and Supplementary Materials

Submission Checklist

Please

Authors are expected to read the Focus and Scope carefully to ensure that the submitted article is relevant to the scholarly orientation of the journal. All submissions should be prepared using the official Microsoft Word template provided by the journal. Authors must ensure that issues related to publication ethics, originality, plagiarism, authorship, citation format, research data, research integrity, and the responsible use of artificial intelligence have been properly addressed prior to submission. All listed authors must approve the final submitted version. Authors are also encouraged to provide a brief academic biography and ORCID ID during the submission process.

Article Submission Overview

Types of Publications

Tsiqah: Jurnal Studi Hadis dan Tradisi Kenabian accepts original research articles that make a substantial contribution to the study of Hadith, Hadith sciences, Sunnah, and Prophetic traditions. The journal prioritizes articles that demonstrate textual depth, methodological clarity, theoretical relevance, originality, and contribution to international scholarly debates.

The journal welcomes articles on classical Hadith sciences, sanad and matn criticism, takhrij al-hadith, fiqh al-hadith, sharh al-hadith, ‘ilm al-rijal, jarh wa ta‘dil, ‘ilal al-hadith, mukhtalif al-hadith, living Hadith, Hadith manuscripts, Islamic knowledge transmission, digital Hadith studies, online religious authority, artificial intelligence and Hadith studies, Southeast Asian Hadith traditions, and interdisciplinary studies of Prophetic traditions.

Articles that are purely devotional, apologetic, polemical, descriptive without analysis, methodologically unclear, or unrelated to the journal’s Focus and Scope are not suitable for publication.

The recommended article length is approximately 6,000–8,500 words, including references, tables, and notes. Articles submitted to the journal must not have been previously published or simultaneously submitted to another publication.

Submission Process

All articles must be submitted electronically through the journal’s Open Journal System (OJS). The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring the accuracy of all submitted information and confirming that all co-authors have approved the article. Authors must register and log into the journal submission system before uploading the article and supplementary files.

Accepted File Formats

Articles must be prepared in Microsoft Word (.doc or .docx) format using the official journal template. Authors are encouraged to insert tables, figures, illustrations, and transliteration tables directly into the main text near their first citation. Any identifying information related to the authors should be removed from the article file prior to peer review to maintain the integrity of the double-blind review process.

Supplementary files may be submitted in common non-proprietary formats where necessary.

Article Preparation

General Considerations

Research articles submitted to Tsiqah: Jurnal Studi Hadis dan Tradisi Kenabian should consist of the following components:

Title

Author Information and Affiliations

Abstract and Keywords

Introduction

Method

Results and Discussion

Conclusion

Acknowledgments, if applicable

Funding Statement, if applicable

References

Arabic transliteration must be applied consistently throughout the article. Authors are encouraged to follow internationally recognized transliteration standards. Terms such as Hadith, Sunnah, sanad, matn, isnad, takhrij, sharh, rijal al-hadith, jarh wa ta‘dil, ‘ilal al-hadith, mukhtalif al-hadith, fiqh al-hadith, ulama, ijazah, and living Hadith may be written in widely accepted academic forms, provided that consistency is maintained throughout the article.

Front Matter

Title

The title must be concise, specific, and academically relevant, clearly reflecting the focus and contribution of the study. Authors are encouraged to avoid abbreviations, overly general titles, devotional expressions, or rhetorical titles. The title should be written in English and preferably contain approximately 15–20 words.

Author Information and Affiliations

Authors’ full names must be written without academic titles. Institutional affiliations and countries must be clearly stated. One corresponding author must be identified along with an active email address. Authors are encouraged to include ORCID IDs where available.

Abstract

The abstract must function as a complete and concise miniature of the article, presenting the research problem as introduced in the Introduction, the methodological approach employed in the Method section, the principal findings derived from the Results, and the core scholarly contribution developed in the Discussion and Conclusion. The abstract should provide a coherent overview of the entire study without introducing new information that is not discussed in the main text.

Authors are expected to briefly explain the background of the study, research objective, methodological approach, major findings, and theoretical contribution of the research. The abstract must be written in a single paragraph consisting of approximately 200–250 words. The abstract must not contain citations, undefined abbreviations, unsupported claims, or excessive technical details.

Keywords

Authors must include 3–5 keywords written in lowercase and separated by commas. Keywords should represent the principal concepts discussed in the article and support indexing and discoverability in international academic databases. Authors are encouraged to use specific and discipline-relevant keywords, such as hadith criticism, living hadith, sanad, matn, digital hadith studies, prophetic traditions, Islamic authority, or Southeast Asian Islam.

Research Article Sections

Introduction

The introduction should systematically position the study within a broader scholarly and socio-intellectual context by moving from general discussion to specific research problems. Authors are expected to explain the broader research context, including relevant global or contemporary issues, empirical realities, and the significance of the topic within Hadith studies, Sunnah studies, Prophetic traditions, Islamic intellectual history, or related disciplines.

The introduction must clearly identify the specific research problem, theoretical tension, interpretive debate, methodological limitation, or unresolved scholarly issue addressed in the study. Authors are required to provide a concise and critical review of relevant previous studies in order to position the article within existing scholarship by synthesizing major scholarly trends, approaches, and debates rather than listing studies individually.

A clear and explicit research gap, whether conceptual, methodological, empirical, textual, interpretive, historical, or contextual, must be identified as the principal justification for the study. The introduction must also formulate focused research questions and clearly state the research objectives. Authors should briefly introduce the main theoretical framework, concepts, or analytical perspectives employed in the study and explain their relevance to the research problem.

The introduction should conclude with a concise statement emphasizing the academic significance, theoretical contribution, and explicit novelty of the study as its principal scholarly contribution.

Method

The method section must provide sufficient detail to allow the study to be understood and academically evaluated. Authors should clearly describe the research design, whether qualitative, quantitative, mixed methods, textual, philological, historical, hermeneutical, comparative, ethnographic, bibliometric, systematic literature review, or digital humanities-based.

For textual Hadith studies, authors must explain the primary sources, criteria for source selection, hadith collections used, analytical framework, and interpretive procedure. For sanad and matn studies, authors should clarify the method of authentication, comparison of narrations, source verification, and analytical criteria. For manuscript studies, authors must describe the manuscript source, repository, codicological information, textual condition, and editorial or analytical method.

For empirical or living Hadith studies, authors should describe the research setting, participants or data sources, data collection techniques, ethical considerations, and data analysis procedures. For digital Hadith studies, authors should explain the platform, digital corpus, tools, sampling procedure, coding strategy, computational method if applicable, and limitations of the digital analysis.

Any modification to established methods must be clearly justified. Authors are expected to demonstrate methodological transparency and ensure that the selected method is appropriate for addressing the research objectives.

Results and Discussion

The Results and Discussion section constitutes the analytical core of the article and must be organized systematically in each sub-section. Authors should begin each discussion with a clear topic sentence presenting the principal finding or argument.

Findings must be supported by specific data, textual evidence, Hadith sources, sanad or matn analysis, primary Arabic sources, field materials, manuscripts, digital corpora, or documented sources with appropriate citations. The findings should be analyzed using the theoretical framework introduced earlier. The discussion must critically engage with previous studies and demonstrate whether the findings support, refine, expand, or challenge existing theories and scholarship.

Authors are also expected to explain the theoretical implications, methodological significance, and academic contribution of the findings. Each sub-section should conclude with a concise statement reinforcing the principal analytical point. Tables, figures, manuscript images, diagrams, and illustrations should be integrated within this section and properly captioned.

Conclusion

The conclusion must provide concise and direct answers to the research objectives and synthesize the principal findings into a coherent academic argument. Authors should highlight the theoretical contribution, academic significance, broader implications of the study, and possible directions for future research.

The conclusion must not merely repeat the abstract or restate descriptive findings. It should not introduce new arguments, new citations, or additional data that have not been discussed in the article.

Acknowledgments

If applicable, this section is dedicated to any parties who contributed significantly to the production or preparation of the article. This may include research grant sponsors, academic advisors, initial readers, research assistants, institutional support, collaborators, manuscript repository staff, translators, or technical assistance.

References and Citation Style

References must follow the Chicago Manual of Style, 17th Edition, Notes and Bibliography system, using footnotes for citations. Authors must use full bibliographic notes at first citation and shortened notes for subsequent citations. A complete bibliography must be provided at the end of the article and arranged alphabetically by the authors’ last names.

Authors are expected to demonstrate strong engagement with international scholarship. Articles should use recent and relevant scholarly sources, particularly peer-reviewed journal articles, academic books, edited volumes, primary Arabic sources, Hadith collections, critical editions, manuscripts, and reputable digital academic resources. Articles should contain approximately 20–35 references, with a strong preference for peer-reviewed and internationally recognized sources. DOI numbers should be included whenever available.

Authors are strongly encouraged to use reference management software such as Zotero, Mendeley, or EndNote to ensure consistency and accuracy in Chicago footnote formatting.

Examples of Chicago Footnote Style

First footnote citation for a book:

Jonathan A. C. Brown, Hadith: Muhammad’s Legacy in the Medieval and Modern World (Oxford: Oneworld, 2009), 45.

Shortened subsequent citation:

Brown, Hadith, 52.

Bibliography entry for a book:

Brown, Jonathan A. C. Hadith: Muhammad’s Legacy in the Medieval and Modern World. Oxford: Oneworld, 2009.

First footnote citation for a journal article:

Harald Motzki, “The Musannaf of ‘Abd al-Razzaq al-San‘ani as a Source of Authentic Ahadith of the First Century A.H.,” Journal of Near Eastern Studies 50, no. 1 (1991): 3–4.

Shortened subsequent citation:

Motzki, “The Musannaf of ‘Abd al-Razzaq,” 9.

Bibliography entry for a journal article:

Motzki, Harald. “The Musannaf of ‘Abd al-Razzaq al-San‘ani as a Source of Authentic Ahadith of the First Century A.H.” Journal of Near Eastern Studies 50, no. 1 (1991): 1–21.

First footnote citation for a classical Arabic source:

Abu ‘Abd Allah Muhammad ibn Isma‘il al-Bukhari, Sahih al-Bukhari, Kitab al-‘Ilm, Bab Man Su’ila ‘Ilman wa Huwa Mushtaghil, no. 59.

Shortened subsequent citation:

Al-Bukhari, Sahih al-Bukhari, no. 59.

Bibliography entry for a classical Arabic source:

Al-Bukhari, Abu ‘Abd Allah Muhammad ibn Isma‘il. Sahih al-Bukhari. Beirut: Dar Ibn Kathir, 2002.

Arabic Transliteration

Arabic terms, names, and titles must be transliterated consistently throughout the article. Authors may use a simplified academic transliteration system, provided that it is applied consistently. Technical Hadith terms such as sanad, matn, isnad, takhrij al-hadith, jarh wa ta‘dil, ‘ilal al-hadith, mukhtalif al-hadith, sharh al-hadith, fiqh al-hadith, ‘ilm al-rijal, and asbab wurud al-hadith should be written consistently.

Qur’anic verses and Hadith texts may be written in Arabic script when necessary, followed by translation and proper citation. Authors are responsible for ensuring the accuracy of Arabic quotations, translations, transliterations, and references.

Tables, Figures, and Supplementary Materials

Figures, tables, charts, schemes, manuscript images, diagrams, and illustrations should be placed near their first citation in the article and numbered consecutively. Each table and figure must include a concise title and explanatory caption. High-resolution images are strongly recommended to ensure publication quality.

Tables should be created using the table function in Microsoft Word. Figures and images should be submitted in high resolution, preferably 300 dpi or higher. All visual materials must be original or used with proper permission and citation.

Supplementary materials may be submitted separately if necessary. These may include datasets, images, appendices, interview guides, transliteration lists, manuscript descriptions, digital corpus materials, coding sheets, or additional tables. Authors are encouraged to make supporting datasets available whenever ethically and legally possible in order to promote research transparency and scholarly reproducibility.

Ethical Requirements

Authors must ensure that the submitted manuscript complies with publication ethics and research integrity standards. The manuscript must be original, free from plagiarism, and not under consideration elsewhere. Any use of previously published material must be properly cited.

Research involving human participants, interviews, fieldwork, online communities, social media data, or identifiable personal information must explain how consent, confidentiality, anonymity, and data protection were addressed. Authors conducting digital research must clearly distinguish between public and private data and must protect the dignity and privacy of individuals or communities.

Authors must disclose any conflict of interest, funding support, or institutional relationship that may influence the research. If there is no conflict of interest, authors should state that there is no conflict of interest.

Use of Artificial Intelligence

Authors must disclose any use of artificial intelligence or AI-assisted tools in the preparation of the manuscript. AI tools may be used for language editing, proofreading, translation assistance, formatting, or technical support, but they must not replace the author’s intellectual responsibility. AI tools cannot be listed as authors.

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of the submitted manuscript. If AI-assisted tools were used, authors should include a brief statement explaining the nature and extent of their use.